Confident in Consumer Confidence?

In September 2008, the subprime mortgage crisis reached a crescendo. Several banks asked for government bailouts and loans or filed for bankruptcy. Mortgage guarantors Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac were placed in conservatorship. The Federal Reserve and central banks around the world scrambled to pump liquidity into the credit markets. To top it all off, the world’s stock markets drifted lower as the crisis unfolded.

At the time, it seemed as though the sky was falling. No surprise then that the consumer confidence index (CCI) fell to what was then the lowest point recorded to that point. The October reading was 38.8 points, more than two times lower than it was a year earlier.¹

You are no doubt familiar with the CCI because the news media faithfully reports it every month. But how useful is this economic indicator to individual investors?

Lag of Confidence

The CCI measures the public’s confidence in the health of the U.S. economy, which can be useful in anticipating future spending patterns. To calculate the CCI, The Conference Board polls 5,000 households who rate current and expected business conditions for their regions. Their answers are used to create a numeric score, which rises when consumers are confident and falls when they are not confident.

One study of the CCI dating back to 1977 found that the index has some correlation to stock market performance, but it’s not what you might expect. In general, large jumps in consumer confidence were followed, on average, by sub-par returns. Conversely, large drops usually preceded above-average returns.²

Another study found that consumer confidence erodes when stock prices decline, but low CCI readings are more likely to be followed by high stock returns than low returns.³

The lesson here is that a low CCI is not always bad news, and a high CCI is not always good. The consumer confidence index can be a useful tool, but it should play only a minor role in your overall outlook.

1) Haver Analytics, 2009
2–3) MarketWatch, May 27, 2009

The information in this article is not intended as tax or legal advice, and it may not be relied on for the purpose of avoiding any federal tax penalties. You are encouraged to seek tax or legal advice from an independent professional advisor. The content is derived from sources believed to be accurate. Neither the information presented nor any opinion expressed constitutes a solicitation for the purchase or sale of any security. This material was written and prepared by Emerald. © 2009 Emerald.

Distinct Financial Solutions is a TX based multiple line insurance agency and Joel Hays is an Agent representing American National Insurance Company and American National Property And Casualty Company. Distinct Financial Solutions and Joel Hays are licensed to sell insurance products in the following states: TX

All products, coverages, and options are not available in all states, and eligibility requirements will apply. Products and services referenced in this website are provided through multiple companies. Each company has financial responsibility only for its own products and services and is not responsible for the products and services provided by the other companies.

Life insurance and annuities are issued through American National Insurance Company, Galveston, Texas.

Personal and commercial lines insurance is issued by American National Property And Casualty Company (ANPAC^®), its subsidiaries or affiliates, including American National General Insurance Company, Pacific Property And Casualty Company (California), American National Lloyds Insurance Company (Texas), American National County Mutual Insurance Company (serviced by ANPAC^®-Texas), and ANPAC^® Louisiana Insurance Company (Louisiana). American National Property And Casualty Company is a subsidiary of American National Insurance Company.

Disability Income products and services are issued by Illinois Mutual Life Insurance Company, Peoria, Illinois.

Securities products and services are offered through Agents who are also Registered Representatives and are distributed by Securities Management and Research, Inc. (SM&R), Member FINRA, SIPC, a broker-dealer subsidiary of American National Insurance Company located at 2450 South Shore Blvd., League City, TX 77573 (281) 334-2469. Please note that Distinct Financial Solutions and SM&R are not affiliated. Securities products are offered by prospectus only, involve investment risks, are subject to market fluctuations and the possible loss of principal.

For more information on the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA), you may visit their Web site at www.finra.org.

Investors may obtain more information about the Securities Investor Protection Corporation (SIPC), including the SIPC brochure, by contacting SIPC at 202-371-8300 or visit www.sipc.org.

Tax issues that may be discussed are subject to change and this is for your information only. Discussion of such issues does not constitute tax or legal advice. Please consult your tax advisor, attorney or CPA for guidance on all tax matters.

These brief descriptions of coverages available are for illustrative purposes only, and are not intended as a statement of contract. For actual terms and conditions of coverage provided, refer to your insurance policy, or, for more information about coverage options and availability, talk to your American National agent and eligibility guidelines apply. American National Family of Companies reserves the right to discontinue programs at any time.

This site may have links to other sites, which are not maintained by American National Insurance Company, its subsidiaries or affiliates. Such links do not imply endorsement or approval of these sites or the content therein by American National, its subsidiaries or affiliates.